Tag: Composite Supply GST

  • How to Reply GST Notice u/s 73 : Complete Step-by-Step Guide (2026)

    How to Reply GST Notice u/s 73 : Complete Step-by-Step Guide (2026)

    By Dr. Haresh Adwani, PhD (Commerce), Law Graduate, Adwani and Company

    Received a GST notice under Section 73? Don’t panic. Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017 deals with cases where tax has not been paid, short paid, or input tax credit (ITC) has been wrongly
    availed but without any intention of fraud or wilful misstatement. These are routine tax demand notices and can be resolved smoothly with the right response. This complete 2026 guide walks you through everything: what the notice means, when it is issued, the time limits, a step-by-step reply process, required documents, penalties for ignoring it, and answers to the most common questions taxpayers ask.


    What’s in This Guide

    • What is a Section 73 GST Notice?
    • When is it Issued? (With scenario table)
    • Time Limits to Reply — Key Deadlines
    • Step-by-Step Reply Process (7 Steps)
    • Documents Required
    • What is a Section 73 GST Notice?
    • Penalties if You Ignore the Notice
    • 7 FAQs Answered by CA Experts
    • Case Study: How Adwani & Co Saved a Client

    What is a GST Notice Under Section 73?

    Legal Definition: Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017 empowers a proper officer to issue a show cause notice (SCN) to a registered taxpayer when tax has not been paid, has been short-paid, erroneously refunded, or when ITC has been wrongly availed or utilised without any element of fraud or intentional misstatement.

    In plain terms: the GST department has identified a mismatch or gap in your returns/tax payment, and they want you to explain or pay up without accusing you of fraud (that would be Section 74).


    When is a Section 73 Notice Issued?

    The GST officer may issue a Section 73 notice in any of these situations:

    ScenarioCommon Reason Risk Level
    GSTR-3B vs GSTR-2A/2B
    mismatch
    ITC claimed but not reflected in supplier’s
    data
    Medium
    GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B mismatchOutput tax declared in GSTR-1 but not paidMedium
    Short payment of taxTax due > tax depositedMedium
    Excess ITC claimedITC beyond eligible limit claimedHigh
    Erroneous refundRefund granted but conditions not metHigh
    Non-payment by unregistered personTax liability exists but GST not paidHigh
    Annual return discrepancyGSTR-9/9C data doesn’t match returnsMedium

    Time Limits — What You Must Know

    Understanding time limits under Section 73 is critical. Missing a deadline converts a manageable notice into a serious penalty situation.

    ActionTime LimitConsequence if Missed
    Voluntary payment
    BEFORE SCN
    Anytime before SCN is issuedNo SCN issued; no penalty
    Payment after SCN but
    within 30 days
    Within 30 days of SCNNo penalty payable
    Reply / Show Cause responseAs stated in notice (usually 30 days)Ex-parte order passed against you
    Officer’s order issuance (DRC-07)Within 3 years from the due date of annual returnN/A — legal deadline for officer
    SCN issuance deadlineAt least 3 months before order
    deadline
    SCN can be challenged as
    time-barred
    SCN can be challenged as time-barred
    Appeal against order3 months from date of orderForfeiture of appeal right

    Important 2026 Update: The Finance Act 2024 extended the time limit for issuance of orders under Section 73 for FY 2018-19 to FY 2021-22. If you receive a notice for these years now, it is still valid. Always verify the notice date and consult a CA immediately.

    Received a notice and unsure of your deadline? (Consult Adwani & Co — Get Expert Review in 24 Hours)

    Also Read https://www.adwaniandco.com/blog/gst-show-cause-notices


    Step by Step: How to Reply to GST Notice u/s 73

    Step 1: Read the Notice Carefully (DRC-01)
    Identify the financial year, the tax period, the amount demanded (CGST/SGST/IGST/Cess separately), the reason for notice, and the response deadline. Check if it is a SCN (Show Cause Notice) or a pre-SCN intimation (DRC-01A).


    Step 2: Analyse the Discrepancy
    Download your GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-2A/2B, and GSTR-9 for the relevant period. Cross check the department’s claim against your own records. Identify whether the demand is correct, partially correct, or incorrect.

    Step 3: Decide Your Response Strategy
    Three options:
    (a) Accept the demand and pay — no penalty within 30 days of SCN
    (b) Partially agree — pay agreed portion and contest the rest
    (c) Fully contest — file a detailed reply with supporting documents

    Step 4 : Prepare Your Reply (GST Notice Reply Format)

    Draft a point-by-point reply addressing each allegation in the SCN. Refer to the specific paragraph numbers in the notice. Use DRC-06 form for filing the reply on the GST portal.
    Attach all supporting documents and a clear reconciliation statement.


    Step 5 : File the Reply on GST Portal
    Log in at gstin.gov.in → Services → User Services → View Notices and Orders → Click on the relevant notice → Submit reply using DRC-06. Attach documents (PDF, max 5MB each).
    Preserve the ARN (Acknowledgement Reference Number) after submission.


    Step 6 : Attend Personal Hearing (If Called)
    If the officer schedules a personal hearing, attend it (or send an authorised representative). Carry original documents and a point-wise argument sheet. Request adjournments in writing via the portal if needed.


    Step 7 : Track the Order & Take Next Steps
    After hearing, the officer issues DRC-07 (Demand Order). If the order is in your favour no further action needed. If you disagree with the order, file an appeal before the Appellate Authority (GST APL-01) within 3 months.


    Documents Required to Reply to Section 73 Notice

    • GSTR-1 for the relevant period
    • GSTR-3B for the relevant period
    • GSTR-2A / 2B reconciliation statement
    • GSTR-9 (Annual Return)
    • Purchase invoices (basis for ITC claimed)
    • Sales invoices for the disputed period
    • Bank statements
    • Previous hearing orders (if any)
    • Supplier correspondence (if disputing ITC)
    • E-way bills (if applicable)
    • Books of accounts / ledgers
    • CA-certified reconciliation statement

    Pro Tip: Always submit a reconciliation statement along with your reply even if the officer didn’t specifically ask for it. It demonstrates good faith and helps resolve the matter faster.

    Penalties if You Ignore the GST Notice u/s 73

    Do NOT ignore a Section 73 notice. Here is what happens:

    Situation Penalty / Consequence
    No reply filed within stipulated
    time
    Ex-parte order passed; demand confirmed automatically
    Demand confirmed via DRC-07Interest @ 18% p.a. on unpaid tax + 10% penalty
    Ignoring confirmed demandRecovery action: bank attachment, asset seizure
    Non-payment after orderCertificate issued to Tax Recovery Officer; property recovery
    Minimum penalty u/s 73Higher of ₹10,000 or 10% of tax dues

    Important: If you voluntarily pay the tax within 30 days of the Show Cause Notice you pay zero penalty. This is the most important window to act quickly.


    Real Case Study – Adwani & Co

    Textile Wholesaler Pune | GST Notice for ITC Mismatch (FY 2021-22)
    A Pune-based textile wholesaler received a Section 73 SCN for ₹18.4 lakhs alleging ITC claimed on invoices not reflecting in GSTR-2B. The client had missed the response deadline and
    an ex-parte order was already issued.

    Demand Raised ₹18.4 Lakhs
    Final Settled Amount ₹2.1 Lakhs
    Demand Waived 89%
    Our team filed a rectification application with full reconciliation proving 87% of the ITC was
    valid with supplier invoices and payment proof. Penalty was fully waived.
    Handled by Adwani & Co, 2023


    Frequently Asked Questions

    01.What is the GST notice reply format PDF / which form do I use?

    You file your reply using Form GST DRC-06 on the GST portal. It allows you to submit a
    written reply, upload supporting documents, and indicate whether you agree/disagree with the demand. There is no separate “PDF format” the reply is filed online through the portal. You
    can prepare a detailed written representation offline and upload it as a PDF attachment with DRC-06.

    02.How to reply to a GST notice — is it the same as an income tax notice?

    No. Income tax notices are handled under the Income Tax Act 1961 via the Income Tax portal
    (incometax.gov.in), while GST notices are handled under CGST Act 2017 via the GST portal (gst.gov.in). The forms, deadlines, and processes are completely different. This guide covers GST notices only.

    03.What is the time limit to reply to a GST notice u/s 73?

    The reply deadline is mentioned in the notice itself — typically 30 days from the date of the
    notice. If you need more time, you can request an extension in writing via the portal. If you
    received an intimation (DRC-01A) before the SCN, you have 30 days to pay or explain before the formal SCN is issued.

    04.Can I avoid paying the penalty under Section 73?

    Yes — if you pay the full tax demand within 30 days of receiving the Show Cause Notice
    (SCN), no penalty is levied under Section 73(8). If you pay voluntarily even before the SCN is
    issued (upon receiving DRC-01A), you pay zero penalty and no SCN is even issued.

    Q5. What if I disagree with the entire demand?

    You file a detailed reply via DRC-06 on the GST portal, contesting each point with evidence
    invoices, ledgers, reconciliation statements, etc. The officer will schedule a personal hearing. If the order still goes against you, you can appeal before the GST Appellate Authority (GST APRIL-01) within 3 months of the order.

    Q6. Is Section 73 notice serious? Will I face criminal action?

    Section 73 notices are civil/tax proceedings — not criminal. Criminal prosecution under GST
    applies only to Section 132 offences involving fraud, fake invoicing, or tax evasion above ₹5
    crore. A Section 73 notice (no fraud element) will not result in criminal action if you respond
    properly. However, ignoring it will lead to demand orders and recovery proceedings.

    Q7. Can I hire a CA or tax consultant to handle the GST notice reply?

    Absolutely and it is strongly recommended for demands above ₹1 lakh or complex ITC
    mismatch cases. A qualified CA can review the notice, identify errors in the department’s claim,
    prepare a legally sound reply, represent you in hearings, and negotiate settlements. Adwani & Co specialises in GST notice handling with a 90%+ success rate in demand reduction

    About the Author
    Dr. Haresh Adwani
    Ph.D. in Commerce | Law Graduate | Managing Partner, Adwani & Co LLP Dr. Haresh Adwani holds a Ph.D. in Commerce and is a qualified Law graduate with over two decades of hands-on experience in GST advisory, direct taxation, and statutory compliance for businesses across Pune and Maharashtra. As Managing Partner of Adwani & Co LLP a firm established in 1977 by Advocate N. T. Adwani Dr. Adwani has guided hundreds of
    SMEs, startups, and corporates through India’s evolving tax landscape. He is a recognised advisor on GST compliance, company formation, and Virtual CFO services, and regularly
    contributes to professional seminars and industry forums in Pune.


  • Are You Paying GST on Inpatient Medicines Unnecessarily?

    The Billing Format Error Most Hospitals Make

    There is a mistake happening quietly inside hundreds of hospitals and nursing homes across India right now.

    It is not a calculation error. It is not a missing document. It is not even a wrong rate applied.

    It is a formatting decision one that most billing teams made years ago without realising it had a direct GST consequence and it is costing healthcare providers real money, every single day.

    GST on Inpatient Medicines
    GST on Inpatient Medicines

    What the Law Actually Says

    The GST framework in India treats healthcare supply as a composite service when it is delivered to an admitted (in-patient) individual. Under this principle consistently upheld by the Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) in Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Karnataka the following position has been firmly established:

    Medicines and consumables supplied to in-patients, billed as part of a single consolidated treatment invoice → Fully exempt from GST.

    The same medicines, raised on a separate standalone invoice → Taxable.

    This is not a loophole. It is not a grey area. It is the intended design of the exemption. The law recognises that in-patient treatment is a bundled, continuous healthcare service and that medicines, consumables, diagnostics and room charges are all components of that single service.

    The exemption, however, only holds when the billing structure reflects that reality.

    The moment you unbundle the moment medicines go on a separate invoice you step outside the composite supply framework. And GST applies.


    Also Read

    https://adwaniandco.com/blog/fo-trading-taxation-in-india-2026-complete-simple-guide


    The Three Gaps Most Healthcare Providers Are Sitting On

    Gap 1: Separate Invoices for In-Patient Medicines

    This is the most common and most expensive gap. If your billing software is raising a distinct invoice for pharmacy items even for admitted patients you are almost certainly paying GST you do not owe.

    The fix is not a legal battle. It is a billing structure review.

    Ex:-Ramesh is admitted. All charges on one bill. Hospital saves GST. Patient saves money.

    Gap 2: Room Rent Above ₹5,000 Per Day

    Room rent for in-patients is exempt from GST up to ₹5,000 per day. Beyond that threshold, GST applies and most hospital billing systems are not configured to flag this automatically.

    If your hospital has premium or single-occupancy rooms priced above ₹5,000 per day, this is a live exposure. It is also an area that gets scrutinised during GST audits.

    Ex:-Same Ramesh. Same medicines. But pharmacy gave a separate bill. Now GST comes in.

    Gap 3: Out-Patient Medicines No Bundling Protection

    It is important to be clear here: the composite supply exemption only applies to in-patients. Medicines dispensed to out-patients  even through the hospital’s own pharmacy do not benefit from the bundling protection. They are taxable as a supply of goods, regardless of the clinical context.

    Many hospitals assume the exemption extends to their OPD pharmacy. It does not. If your OPD dispensing is not being taxed correctly, that is a separate compliance gap worth addressing.

    A nursing home spending ₹15 lakhs monthly on inpatient medicines, billed separately, could be paying ₹1.8 to ₹2.7 lakhs in avoidable GST every year simply because of invoice format.

    Example:

    Seema visits doctor, gets medicine from hospital pharmacy and goes home. She was never admitted. No bundling protection. GST applies always.


    Why This Is Happening And Why It Stays Hidden

    This is not a situation most hospitals discover through a notice or an audit. It surfaces only when someone looks at the billing structure specifically through a GST lens.

    Billing systems are typically designed for clinical and operational efficiency. They are built to generate bills quickly, track inventory and satisfy insurance formats. GST compliance is often an afterthought or worse, it was configured once during implementation and has not been reviewed since. The result is that the exemption erodes silently. Not in a courtroom. Not in a demand notice. Inside the invoicing system, on every bill, every day.


    What a Billing Structure Review Actually Looks Like

    Identifying and closing these gaps does not require a lengthy engagement or a complete system overhaul.

    In most cases, it involves:

    • Reviewing how your billing software currently segregates medicine and treatment charges for in-patients
    • Confirming whether your room categories are mapped correctly against the ₹5,000 threshold
    • Checking how OPD pharmacy transactions are being classified and taxed
    • Aligning your invoice format with the composite supply position established in AAR rulings

    The legal protection is already there. The question is whether your billing structure is positioned to use it.


    A Note on the AAR Rulings

    The Authority for Advance Rulings is not a random opinion. It is a formal statutory mechanism through which taxpayers obtain binding clarifications on GST positions.

    The rulings from Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Karnataka on composite hospital billing have been consistent in their direction: when in-patient care is billed as a unified service, the GST exemption for healthcare services extends to the medicines and consumables included in that bill.

    These rulings do not create new law. They confirm what the law already provides. But they also make the billing format requirement explicit which is precisely why format matters as much as substance here.

    1.Are medicines given to admitted patients exempt from GST in India?

    Yes but only if they are billed as part of a single composite treatment invoice. If medicines are raised on a separate pharmacy bill, GST applies even for admitted patients

    2. What is composite supply in GST for hospitals?

    Composite supply means all services and goods given to an admitted patient medicines, room, doctor fees, equipment are bundled into ONE single bill. The government then treats it as a healthcare service and gives full GST exemption.

    3.Does GST apply on room rent in hospitals?

    Room rent up to ₹5,000 per day is fully exempt from GST. If your hospital charges more than ₹5,000 per day for a room GST applies on the entire room rent amount.

    4.Is GST applicable on OPD medicines in hospitals?

    Yes. Out-patient medicines are always taxable under GST regardless of whether they come from the hospital’s own pharmacy. The GST exemption only covers admitted (in-patient) treatment.

    5.What are AAR rulings and why do they matter for hospitals?

    AAR stands for Authority for Advance Rulings. It is an official government body that gives binding legal clarifications on GST questions. AAR rulings from Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Karnataka have clearly confirmed that composite hospital billing qualifies for full GST exemption making these rulings very important for healthcare providers.

    Author

    Dr. Haresh Adwani

    PhD (Commerce) · Adwani & Company, Pune

    Dr. Haresh Adwani is a PhD holder in Commerce with over 20 years of experience in NRI taxation, FEMA compliance, international financial advisory, and tax notice resolution. He is one of Pune’s most trusted NRI tax advisors, specialising in residential status assessment, DTAA planning, and cross-border compliance for professionals returning from the US, UK, UAE, Canada, and Australia.